Introduction Last week, I wrote an online comment on the nature and ambit of the Sultan of Perak’s powers (see www.loyarburok.com here), basing my thoughts on the High Court decision in that case. Shortly afterwards, two of the three Court of Appeal judgments – those of Dato’ Raus Sharif and Dato’ Ahmad Maarop JJCA – […]
Posted inCase Notes
MB v MB Appeal: 3 Questions for the FCT
Date: July 9, 2009 Coram: Alauddin Sheriff, Arifin Zakaria, Zulkefli Makinudin FCJJ
Posted inFood, Drink &...
The Government’s shame: Taman Sinar Harapan and the failure to respect, protect and fulfill ESCR
During the Universal Periodic Review of Malaysia’s human rights record by the United Nations Human Rights Council, a process which concluded on 12 June 2009, Malaysia received high and plentiful praise from countries from ASEAN, the Organisation of the Islamic Conference and the Non-Aligned Movement. According to these countries, Malaysia had achieved great strides in […]
Posted inExpress Yourself
FFF Shoot Day 4 “No Silver Lining: The Perak Crisis”
Day 4. Our schedule was pushed behind when it rained heavily in the morning.
Posted inThank God It's Friday
Jalan Duta High Court and Singing Chickens
Strange things happen at the Jalan Duta High Court. However, you may not experience them if you go there expecting to find them. For they are strange, but they are also shy.
Posted inTalking about Lawyers
The Art of Cross-Examination: Gentleman, Coffin Nail & Prebet Adam
Cross-examining a witness is a skill which is neither easy nor too difficult to embrace. To be a good criminal defence lawyer you have to learn the “curves” the hard way.
Posted inStupid Me!
Masam Manis Pemansuhan PPSMI
Originally published at CeritaOrangGilak. Hari ini merupakan hari yang masam. Semasam bagai nikah tak suka, bak kata orang tua bila aku kena menapak sejauh 1 kilometer ke Mahkamah Jalan Duta akibat jalan-jalan yang ditutup dan banyaknya kenderaan yang mencuri tempat parkir peguam demi menunjukkan sokongan pada Bapa Reformasi Malaysia (ada ke gelaran tu?). Oh ya… […]
Posted inBolehland
“Tikus-tikus ujian” PPSMI
Maka kerajaan membuat keputusan untuk memansuhkan pengajaran dan pembelajaran Sains dan Matematik dalam bahasa Inggeris (PPSMI). Dasar tersebut, yang dimulakan pada tahun 2003, telah mendapat bantahan dan kritikan dari banyak pihak.
Posted inJudging the Judges
Gobbledegook and regurgitation galore in the 2 written judgments of the Court of Appeal in Zambry v Nizar
Prologue I shall start with an aside on the dictionary definition of the two words which feature in the title of this article. Gobbledegook means unintelligible language. Regurgitate means repeat information without understanding it. Regurgitation is the noun.
Posted inBolehland
Is the EAIC constitutional?
WHEN our Federal Constitution was promulgated in 1957, Part X was designed to deal with public services. Under Article 132, seven areas of public services were identified: the armed forces, the judicial and legal service, the general public service, the police force, the railway service, joint public services (between the federation and one or more […]
Posted inSelected Judgments
CoA’s Outline of Reasons in DSAI v PP (s418A Transfer Issue)
The Outline of Reasons delivered by the Court of Appeal on July 2, 2009 is here. The Court held inter alia: I. On the issue of legitimate expectation that the AG would not in any way partake in the prosecution of DSAI:
Posted inBolehland
Zambry’s Illegal EXCO
Why is Zambry’s EXCO illegal? Let us examine the late Tun Suffian’s interpretation. First, the context. Did Nizar tender the resignation of his EXCO? 1. Thus far, we have been asking the question whether the Sultan (HRH) may dismiss the Menteri Besar (MB). The High Court has ruled that HRH does not have such power, […]
Posted inThe Lobby
Bar Council’s International Justice Day Debate on 15 July 2009
Announcement of Bar Council’s International Justice Day Debate on 15 July 2009
Posted inBolehland
Melayu tidak memerlukan perpaduan politik
Nampaknya isu kerajaan perpaduan, yang diwar-warkan oleh beberapa pemimpin PAS dan dijadikan bahan politik oleh pemimpin UMNO akan berakhir. Pemimpin tertinggi Pakatan Rakyat telah sebulat suara menolak cadangan kerajaan perpaduan. Ketika isu tersebut hangat dibincangkan, para pemimpin UMNO rata-rata begitu menyambut baik cadangan kerajaan perpaduan yang dicadangkan, dengan alasan bahawa sebuah kerajaan perpaduan dapat “memulihkan […]
Posted inSelected Exhortations
NH Chan, A Class Act: Gopal Sri Ram
The following are remarks of Mr Justice Gopal Sri Ram, Federal Court Judge, at the launch of the 2nd edition of retired Justice N H Chan’s book “How to Judge the Judges” on 26 June 2009. LoyarBurok is honoured that we have been, from time to time, allowed to publish his articles. We wish him […]
Posted inThe Lobby
Upholding Human Rights – Hear Raja Aziz Addruse this Friday
The Inaugural Annual Hakam Lecture by Raja Aziz Addruse, on Upholding Human Rights, is this Friday, 3rd July 2009 at 5 pm at Hotel Equatorial, Jalan Sultan Ismail, Kuala Lumpur.
Posted inSelected Judgments
2 Court of Appeal Grounds of Judgment by Raus and Maarop in Zambry v Nizar
Loyarburok makes available the written groudns of Dato’ Md. Raus bin Sharif JCA and Dato’ Ahmad bin Haji Maarop JCA
Posted inCase Notes
“The Sultan has no explicit power to dismiss an MB under the Perak Constitution”, The Sultan’s Constitutional Powers: A Comment
LoyarBurok is privileged to have received this comment piece from Kevin YL Tan on the on-going Perak constitutional crisis. Kevin has taught constitutional law for over 20 years. He currently holds Adjunct Professorships at the Faculty of Law, National University of Singapore and the S Rajaratnam School of International Studies, Nanyang Technological University. He is […]