Comments on: “The Sultan has no explicit power to dismiss an MB under the Perak Constitution”, The Sultan’s Constitutional Powers: A Comment http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/ Fri, 30 Jul 2010 15:48:58 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: London Malaysia Forum » The state of Perak http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-7517 London Malaysia Forum » The state of Perak Wed, 24 Feb 2010 17:38:04 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-7517 [...] The Sultan’s Constitutional Powers: A Comment (re Nizar v Zambry (HC(Malaya)) by Kevin Tan [...] [...] The Sultan’s Constitutional Powers: A Comment (re Nizar v Zambry (HC(Malaya)) by Kevin Tan [...]

]]> By: The Perak Crisis: Keep Focused on the Real Issues http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-5679 The Perak Crisis: Keep Focused on the Real Issues Wed, 04 Nov 2009 04:56:01 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-5679 [...] number of issues were canvassed and discussed. I had previously commented on the correctness of the High Court decision and having already discussed the contradictions that arose from the judgments of Raus and Maarop [...] [...] number of issues were canvassed and discussed. I had previously commented on the correctness of the High Court decision and having already discussed the contradictions that arose from the judgments of Raus and Maarop [...]

]]> By: Loyarburok http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2924 Loyarburok Fri, 10 Jul 2009 06:40:20 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2924 [...] comment on the nature and ambit of the Sultan of Perak’s powers (see www.loyarburok.com here), basing my thoughts on High Court decision in that case. Shortly afterwards, two of the three [...] [...] comment on the nature and ambit of the Sultan of Perak’s powers (see http://www.loyarburok.com here), basing my thoughts on High Court decision in that case. Shortly afterwards, two of the three [...]

]]> By: Janetlee http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2901 Janetlee Thu, 09 Jul 2009 13:26:21 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2901 PLEASE BRING BACK - SEPARATION OF POWERS... Independance of the Judiciary. Regards, Janetlee PLEASE BRING BACK – SEPARATION OF POWERS… Independance of the Judiciary.

Regards,
Janetlee

]]> By: Suara Keadilan Online : English Edition » MB vs MB: The written nonsense of the Appeals Crt judgments http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2882 Suara Keadilan Online : English Edition » MB vs MB: The written nonsense of the Appeals Crt judgments Thu, 09 Jul 2009 03:55:42 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2882 [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...] [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...]

]]> By: Gobbledegook and regurgitation galore « Hornbill Unleashed http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2872 Gobbledegook and regurgitation galore « Hornbill Unleashed Wed, 08 Jul 2009 16:38:42 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2872 [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...] [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...]

]]> By: Loyarburok http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2852 Loyarburok Tue, 07 Jul 2009 15:58:17 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2852 [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...] [...] confidence of the majority of the Assembly? Can he refuse to resign? Professor Kevin YL Tan in his essay which appears on the web portal LoyarBurok (www.loyarburok.com) tells us that: This happened in [...]

]]> By: MatTop http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2827 MatTop Sat, 04 Jul 2009 15:15:53 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2827 I don't agree that the Court is the correct place to settle such dispute in view of the integrity of Malaysian judges. They turn the law upside done to suit Umno. In the sarawak case, the judge was a MatSalleh and his judgement was very sound which was in accord with commonwealth constitutional convention and practices. Why malaysian judges, most of whom are just average students during their secondary school days refused to follow the Serawak's decision. Since Merdeka our education system had produced a lot of intelligent and bright malay students. Almost all of these bright malay students took up either Engineering, Accountancy, medicine, economics and other field of studies. Only the average and not so bright malay students took up Law. that is why the quality and integrity of the malays judges in the Judiciary now are very poor. Eusoffe Chin the former CJ started work as a court interpreter. I don’t agree that the Court is the correct place to settle such dispute in view of the integrity of Malaysian judges. They turn the law upside done to suit Umno. In the sarawak case, the judge was a MatSalleh and his judgement was very sound which was in accord with commonwealth constitutional convention and practices.

Why malaysian judges, most of whom are just average students during their secondary school days refused to follow the Serawak’s decision.

Since Merdeka our education system had produced a lot of intelligent and bright malay students. Almost all of these bright malay students took up either Engineering, Accountancy, medicine, economics and other field of studies. Only the average and not so bright malay students took up Law. that is why the quality and integrity of the malays judges in the Judiciary now are very poor. Eusoffe Chin the former CJ started work as a court interpreter.

]]> By: Lawyer Lua http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2822 Lawyer Lua Sat, 04 Jul 2009 04:20:06 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2822 Do we agree that the Court is the place for us to settle our dispute according to the Law ? Do we agree that the Court is the place for us to settle our dispute according to the Law ?

]]> By: MatTop http://www.loyarburok.com/case-notes/the-sultan-has-no-explicit-power-to-dismiss-an-mb-under-the-perak-constitution-the-sultans-constitutional-powers-a-comment/comment-page-1/#comment-2800 MatTop Thu, 02 Jul 2009 06:57:20 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3110#comment-2800 addendum: Md Yaacob, the Kelantan MB whom a vote of no-confidence was passed by the Assy was an Umno puppet MB. He refused to resign when the Sultan rejected his request for dissolution and instead UmnoBN declared 'a state of emergency' in Kelantan and got to rule Kelantan by the back door. Umno always cause problems lah. In Perak, Kelantan, Sabah and even in Serawak. All court cases on this constitutional issues are the result of Umno's illegal acts. addendum:

Md Yaacob, the Kelantan MB whom a vote of no-confidence was passed by the Assy was an Umno puppet MB. He refused to resign when the Sultan rejected his request for dissolution and instead UmnoBN declared ‘a state of emergency’ in Kelantan and got to rule Kelantan by the back door.

Umno always cause problems lah. In Perak, Kelantan, Sabah and even in Serawak. All court cases on this constitutional issues are the result of Umno’s illegal acts.

]]>